The Judgment of BC

By / Magazine / May 26th, 2016 / 7

Fifteen years ago, it is unlikely that many would even dream that Syrah grown in British Columbia could help draw international attention to the province’s burgeoning wine industry. In fact, beyond Pinot Noir, many questioned the ability of BC producers to grow reds worthy of any attention beyond a novelty interest.

Having judged at Canadian wine competitions for more than a decade, I’ve had the opportunity to taste the evolution of our country’s wines and, for the past several years, BC Syrah has shone. The wines are fresh, elegant, nuanced, fruit-driven, peppery, meaty, expressive and reflective of the sunny, savoury southern Okanagan and Similkameen Valley. Much of this is due to the region’s abundance of sunlight hours during the growing season and significant diurnal temperature fluctuation. The grape’s ability to express the diversity of terroir that exists in the province is also becoming more evident.

I also recently tasted a remarkably well made Syrah from Kelowna produced by Quails’ Gate. Most would presume it to be too cold to ripen the grape in the northern part of the Okanagan, but the winery has a specific site adjacent to the lake which acts as a tempering factor, creating a micro-climate seemingly well suited for the variety.

The quality of the province’s Syrah was reinforced earlier this year at the “Judgment of BC” tasting in Vancouver organized by the British Columbia Wine Institute (BCWI) in conjunction with the 25th anniversary of BC VQA (Vintner’s Quality Alliance, which ensures, among other things, that wines bearing the insignia are made with 100 per cent BC grown grapes). Six BC Syrahs and six Chardonnays were tasted blind with an equivalent number of acknowledged international benchmarks. While BC Syrah excelled, the province’s Chardonnays did not fare as well.

British wine critic Steven Spurrier, consulting editor to Decanter Magazine, chair of the Decanter World Wine Awards and organizer of the 1976 Judgment of Paris (depicted in the movie Bottle Shock) tasted the wines along with 16 Canadian judges, myself included.

Remarkably (or not), BC Syrah finished first, fourth and fifth, reinforcing what some of us already suspected … its quality is comparable to the best in the world.

Syrah results:

CC Jentsch Syrah 2013, Okanagan Valley, BC

Langmeil Shiraz Orphan Bank 2012, Barossa Valley, Australia

Domaine Vincent Paris Cornas Granit 60 2013, Rhône Valley, France

Nichol Syrah 2012, Okanagan Valley, BC

Le Vieux Pin Syrah Cuvée Classique 2013, Okanagan Valley, BC

Ojai Syrah 2011, Santa Barbara, California

Jackson-Triggs Shiraz Sunrock 2010, Okanagan Valley, BC

Orofino Syrah Scout Vineyard 2012, Similkameen Valley, BC

JL Chave Selections Crozes-Hermitage Silene 2012, Rhône Valley, France

Tyrrell’s Shiraz Vat 9 2011, Hunter Valley, Australia

Laughing Stock Syrah 2013, Okanagan Valley, BC

K Vintners Syrah The Beautiful 2012, Walla Walla, Washington


Chardonnay results:

Soumah Chardonnay Single Vineyard 2013, Yarra Valley, Australia

Kumeu River Chardonnay Hunting Hill 2012, Auckland, New Zealand

Hamilton Russell Chardonnay 2014, Hemel-en-Aarde, South Africa

Jean-Marc Brocard Chablis Premier Cru Montmains 2012, Burgundy, France

Bouchard Père & Fils Meursault Premier Cru Genevrieres 2011, Burgundy, France

Blue Mountain Chardonnay Reserve 2012, Okanagan Valley, BC

Tantalus Chardonnay 2012, Okanagan Valley, BC

Robert Mondavi Chardonnay Reserve 2012, Carneros, California

Mission Hill Chardonnay Perpetua 2012, Okanagan Valley, BC

Quails’ Gate Chardonnay Rosemary’s Block 2013, Okanagan Valley, BC

Meyer Family Chardonnay Micro Cuvée 2012, Okanagan Valley, BC

Haywire Chardonnay Canyonview 2013, Okanagan Valley, BC


Acknowledging the fact that there were no bad wines in the lineup (in fact, all were quite well made and deserving of the accolades each has received in the past), it is not surprising that BC Chardonnay did not shine against the international benchmarks. They are, after all, benchmarks, and regions such as Burgundy have been producing the grape for significantly longer than BC. Perhaps, though, producers should look at the results and the success of the Chardonnays from Australia, New Zealand and South Africa as a wake-up call.

Many BC producers often extol the virtues of their Chardonnay, and while many are very good, it seems they are still a work in progress and require some fine tuning (focus more on vineyard and expressing the site in the bottle) to truly stand with the international benchmarks, not by copying them, but by being more distinctly representative of their terroir. This should not be looked on as a knock, but instead, as a reality check, which was the intent of the tasting according to the BCWI: “to honestly assess the current state of grape growing and winemaking in BC to provide a clear perspective … and to achieve a focused vision for the continued evolution of the BC wine industry.”

The Judgment of Paris is often looked at as the catalyst that propelled the California wine industry onto the international stage (California Chardonnay and Cabernet Sauvignon won in both categories against their French counterparts). Will the Judgment of BC have the same effect? Perhaps, but it should, at minimum, cause Canadian wine consumers to take a closer look at BC Syrah and take pride in the fact that we are growing quality wines comparable to some of the best in the world.

The highest praise came from Spurrier, who noted, “For me, wine is the three ‘Ps’: the place, the people and the product. British Columbia ticks all three boxes with exuberance, elegance and conviction.” And quite encouraging were his comments related to viewing BC as a New World wine producing region: “There’s nothing ‘New World’ about what’s going on in BC because ‘New World’ is varietal first, vineyard second. If I’ve seen anything anywhere in the world, apart from France, Italy, Spain and Portugal, which is more vineyard first, varietal second, it’s BC.”

I’ve been saying for years that if the Canadian wine industry is going to evolve and be taken seriously internationally as a quality wine-growing region, we need to benchmark the quality being produced in the country with the rest of the world and not just by Canadian tasters. We’ve seen Canadian wines receive greater exposure to international influencers over the past few years and we must continue to show our wares to those beyond our borders. Canada is growing world-class wines and tastings such as the Judgment of BC will only help make our wines better.

Next judgment in 2016, Riesling and Pinot Noir? I’m looking forward to it.


Editor-in-chief for Quench Magazine, Gurvinder Bhatia left a career practising law to pursue his passion for wine and food. Gurvinder is also the wine columnist for Global Television Edmonton, an international wine judge and the president of Vinomania Consulting. Gurvinder was the owner/founder of Vinomania wine boutique for over 20 years (opened in 1995, closed in 2016) which was recognized on numerous occasions as one of the 20 best wine stores in Canada. Gurvinder was the wine columnist for CBC Radio for 11 years and is certified by Vinitaly International in Verona Italy as an Italian Wine Expert, one of only 15 people currently in the world to have earned the designation. In 2015, Gurvinder was named by Alberta Venture Magazine as one of Alberta’s 50 Most Influential People. He is frequently asked to speak locally, nationally and internationally on a broad range of topics focussing on wine, food, business and community.

Comments are closed.

North America’s Longest Running Food & Wine Magazine

Get Quench-ed!!!

Champion storytellers & proudly independent for over 50 years. Free Weekly newsletter & full digital access