How to Make the Ultimate Meatball Sandwich

By / Food / March 9th, 2015 / 1

In the midst of this winter weather, I am constantly looking for reminders that summer is around the corner, a glimmer of hope that warmer temperatures are coming. In order to achieve this, I start to think about my favourite summer destinations and the foods that remind me of those places.

I love Italy and all the food and smells that come along with it. Is there anything more synonymous with Italian food than the mighty meatball? It wasn’t all that long ago that I had my first meatball sandwich. A-hole-in-the-wall restaurant with 10 items on a chalkboard menu; 20 seats, with non-matching plates. But the food was fantastic. The sandwich combined all the great flavours of Italy, wrapped up in a warm, crusty bun (that always needs to accompany good pasta to soak up the last bits of sauce) and all made it easy to consume. The combination of a crunchy bun, soft dough and a warm sauce just can’t be beat.

I went home and had to recreate it. The flavours were not the hard part to figure out. High-quality simple ingredients will provide a surprisingly rich taste. It was the cooking method that was the tricky part. Finding the right balance of seared meat and soft “fall apart” texture took some trial and error. Browning in a pan, and then transferring to a sauce, yielded a tough meatball. Simply cooking it in sauce from scratch yielded too soft a texture. So off to the oven we went. A short sear (in the oven) followed by baking them in sauce — exactly how I wanted them. My meatball sandwich was created; now about that fresh bread…

These sandwiches are a perfect combo between the hearty winter meals that make us feel cozy and warm, and the fresh flavours of summer tomatoes and pesto that make us want to go outside and bask in the sun.

meatball sandwiches

1 lb ground pork

1 lb ground beef (or veal)

2 whole eggs

3 garlic cloves (chopped)

1/2 cup parsley (chopped)

1/4 cup bread crumbs

1 tbsp oregano, salt and pepper (each)

2 cups tomato sauce (pick your favourite)

6-8 Italian sandwich buns

1 small jar of pesto

Parmesan for grating (to taste)


Preheat oven to 425°F.

Combine pork, beef, eggs, garlic, parsley, bread crumbs, oregano, salt and pepper in a mixing bowl and combine. Mix until all ingredients evenly dispersed

Form mixture into meatballs, each slightly larger than a golf ball. Line in an high-sided ovenproof container in a single layer, so the meatballs are not touching. If mixture is overly sticky, add additional bread crumbs to make it easier to handle.

Bake meatballs for 10 minutes.

Reduce oven temp to 350°F. Add tomato sauce, and place back in the oven for an additional 20 minutes.

Cut sandwich buns lengthwise in half and spread pesto on both sides. Add sauce and meatballs to buns, add Parmesan over hot meatballs, and cover with a little more sauce.

Match: Serve with a nice wicker-covered Chianti (if you can find one).


Comments are closed.

North America’s Longest Running Food & Wine Magazine

Get Quench-ed!!!

Champion storytellers & proudly independent for over 50 years. Free Weekly newsletter & full digital access